Double Standards Regarding Animals as Silent Agents in Legislation: The Case of Wild Fish Welfare in Finland

Saara Kupsala *, Anna Valros *, Laura Hänninen * and Helena Röcklinsberg **

Abstract

Fishing is one of the most widespread forms of wild animal use, yet welfare norms governing this practice remain limited. Recent legislation in Finland aims to improve fish welfare, with both the new Animal Welfare Act (AWA), effective from 2024, and amendments to the Fishing Act introducing provisions on the handling and killing of fish. In the AWA, welfare is grounded in animals’ subjective experiences and respect for their intrinsic value. This article examines how sentience, unnecessary suffering, and respect for fish are constructed in legislative reasoning and stakeholder submissions gathered during public consultation. Our findings show that the reform incorporates animal welfare norms into the Fishing Act, which has historically been weakly connected to the principles of Finnish animal welfare law. Although the reform represents a conceptual advance, its practical impact is limited: customary practices remain largely unchallenged, and large-scale fishing operations are exempt from humane slaughter requirements. Public consultation revealed significant divisions: stakeholders with specific interests in fishing questioned fish sentience, while animal welfare stakeholders challenged traditional practices. The analysis highlights the difficulty of reconciling differing perspectives on fish, as fish are treated both as sentient beings under the AWA and as a natural resource in fishing legislation.

Keywords

Animal welfare law, fish, respect, sentience, unnecessary suffering

Suggested Citation Style:

Kupsala, Saara, Valros, Anna, Hänninen, Laura, and Röcklinsberg, Helena (2026). Double Standards Regarding Animals as Silent Agents in Legislation: The Case of Wild Fish Welfare in Finland. Journal of Animal Law, Ethics and One Health (LEOH), 144-173. DOI: 10.58590/leoh.2026.015

 

* Research Centre for Animal Welfare, Department of Production Animal Medicine, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Helsinki

** Department of Applied Animal Science and Welfare, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine and Animal Science, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences

 

Content

 

I. Introduction

Fishing is one of the most widespread forms of wild animal use globally. Wild fish account for the highest numbers of vertebrates killed by humans for food and feed, with 87.5 per cent stemming from wild catches.[1] Most are wild-caught by large vessels, but recreational catches also account for a substantial number of fish.[2] Despite the scale of this practice and its implications for animal welfare, the animal welfare norms that regulate fishing are generally highly limited.[3] This imbalance is striking in light of extensive scientific evidence demonstrating that fish experience multiple and often severe stressors during capture, including hypoxia, injury, exhaustion, and barotrauma.[4] Furthermore, the failure to practice humane slaughter is common, and recreational fishing is often characterised by competitive practices and release methods that endanger fish welfare.[5]

In this article, we analyse the perception of fish welfare in Finland by focusing on the views of stakeholder organisations and the official reasoning underpinning the recent legislative reform. By examining the government proposal for Finland’s new Animal Welfare Act as well as the response from stakeholder organisations as part of the public consultation, we map the ethical reasoning regarding the capture of wild fish by scrutinising how the concepts of sentience, unnecessary suffering and respect are constructed. Finland provides an interesting setting to examine the positioning of fish in animal welfare legislation. Fishing is deeply embedded in Finnish society, as approximately one third of the population engages in recreational fishing.[6] It has been estimated that the annual catch, comprising both commercial and recreational fishing, is 2.8 billion individuals.[7] While most of the catch by weight derives from commercial marine fisheries, recreational fishing accounts for a significant share – approximately one-fourth in 2024.[8] Recently updated legislation has sought to address fish welfare in Finnish society. Given the high proportion of Finns actively engaged in recreational fishing, we focus on catch-and-release and humane slaughter. To our knowledge, there exists no prior systematic analysis of the animal welfare norms embedded in Finnish fishing legislation.

Despite the magnitude of the animal welfare impacts of fishing, scholarly attention to animal welfare regulations for fishing appears limited. This might reflect a taxonomic bias in the multidisciplinary study of animal welfare law, similar to the one identified in animal behaviour sciences.[9] The legal protection of animals is linked to social perceptions and classifications of them.[10] Fish are phylogenetically more distant from humans than other vertebrates, and human empathy and compassion towards other animals tend to decrease with phylogenetic distance.[11] Shared external characteristics with humans, comprising ‘anthropomorphic stimuli’ for empathy formation, diminish with evolutionary distance, with fish lacking many features homologous with those of humans, such as facial expressions and vocalisations above water.[12] Additionally, people ascribe fewer cognitive and emotional capacities to animals who are phylogenetically more remote from us.[13] Compared to terrestrial animals, people have limited everyday experience and knowledge of the natural behaviour of fish, as they live in aquatic environments, which enhances their moral invisibility.[14] Taken together, these factors challenge our perception of the need to bear ethical responsibility for fish as individuals.[15]

Animal welfare legislation in European countries is based on a welfarist paradigm in which a central principle is the protection of animals from unnecessary suffering.[16] While animal welfare and suffering can be evaluated through scientific methods, determining what constitutes unnecessary suffering is an ethical issue that also involves political and social considerations.[17] What suffering is deemed unnecessary reflects human interests and public opinion,[18] while societal perceptions of the sentience and mental capacities of the animal in question also play a role. In addition to welfare, terms such as dignity, respect, and intrinsic value have been increasingly included in animal welfare legislation in Europe. This mirrors an ideal of regulating human conduct based on respect for the moral value of an animal, above welfare concerns.[19]

Our empirical setting is the comprehensive reform of Finland’s animal welfare legislation, where the earlier Animal Protection Act (247/1996) was replaced by the new Animal Welfare Act (693/2023), effective from 2024.[20] The reform represents a shift in focus from the protection of animals to the promotion of their welfare, along with the inclusion of the concept of respect in Finnish animal welfare law. In parallel, the Fishing Act (379/2015) was amended to include new animal welfare provisions concerning the killing and handling of fish.[21] The revision of legislation provides an opportunity to examine how fish are perceived and positioned in different pieces of legislation regulating the use of wild fish and to assess to what extent the principles of respect and avoidance of suffering are negotiated and applied to encompass the legal protection of fish welfare in fishing practices.

This study focuses on Finnish national law because of the absence of international and European Union (EU) animal welfare regulations for recreational fishing. International law lacks generally binding treaties on animal welfare, while international fisheries law focuses on resource management, conservation, and sustainability.[22] The application of the Finnish Fishing Act is subject to EU legislation concerning the Common Fisheries Policy (CFP), where the Union holds exclusive competence over the conservation of marine biological resources and shared competence over other fishery matters.[23] However, the CFP is designed for commercial fishing, contains minimal regulation of recreational fishing, and – despite Article 13 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the EU recognising animal sentience – contains no binding provisions to protect the welfare of individual wild-caught fish.[24]

In Finland, legislators’ intentions are explained in a government proposal that offers detailed motivation while also serving as the most significant legal source guiding the interpretation and application of the forthcoming law. [25] As part of a preceding mandatory public consultation, citizen and stakeholder views, knowledge, and experiences are collected.[26] These written comments on the draft bill provide information on the viewpoints, opinions, and moral views of stakeholders and the wider public regarding the matter under consideration. While analysing the negotiation of animal welfare norms regulating this widespread animal-use activity is important given the magnitude of the animal welfare impact, we also hope to provide insight into the ethical basis of the legal principles, which can form a useful reference point for analysing the legal protection of wild fish in other legal contexts.

Agency is an important aspect of animal welfare and refers to ‘the capacity for inner motivated behavioural engagement with the environment’, encompassing factors such as making choices, pursuing goals, and developing competencies.[27] Apart from internal capability, agency in the policy process is also a relational phenomenon; an individual’s capacity to contribute to shaping the laws that govern their lives is significantly dependent on social factors that enable agency.[28] Silent agents refer to individuals who possess limited means to participate in the knowledge production of law drafting.[29] Nonhuman animals are excluded from the typical consultation procedures because of biological barriers to participation.[30] In law-drafting processes, human agents speak about them and for them, at best assuming the role of moral agents acting on their behalf. The facilitation of nonhuman animal agency in the policy process requires specific structures, such as expert bodies representing animal perspectives.[31] We consider fish to be a particularly silent group of nonhuman animals due to an evolutionary and environmental gap in humans’ ability to interpret their subjective experiences.

Drawing on sociology, animal ethics, and animal welfare science, this article examines how sentience, unnecessary suffering, and respect are constructed in relation to the legal protection of fish in Finland. The empirical analysis of stakeholder opinions is informed by a sociological perspective, while an animal ethics perspective is applied to the ethical scrutiny of the core concepts of legislation. We reflect on our analysis in relation to the current scientific understanding of fish sentience and welfare, informed by animal welfare science. Although we utilise the animal law literature, our analysis is not a legal study and is not based on any particular legal schools of thought.

We have employed the following constraints to the scope of our analysis: while crustaceans were included in the revision of the Finnish Fishing Act, we focus on fish, comparing their positioning in relation to other vertebrates. Additionally, we examine welfare regulations regarding the treatment of individual fish; hence, we do not consider conservation legislation, except when we relate welfare regulations to the biodiversity preservation and sustainability objectives of the fishing legislation. Further, our attention is focused on the new Finnish animal welfare legislation, and we do not conduct any systematic comparison with the legislation in other countries. We also set aside the Finnish criminal code and its definition of unnecessary suffering. Given the focus on the governmental proposal preceding actual legislation, we do not discuss the supervision and implementation of the legislation.

The article is structured as follows: We first provide the necessary context by examining the scientific literature on fish sentience and welfare, public perceptions of these issues, and the societal context of fishing in Finland (Section II). We then outline the national legal framework, focusing on the new Animal Welfare Act and the amended Fishing Act (Section III). After presenting our materials and methods (Section IV), we deliver the core empirical analysis (Section V). This section is organised around the construction of three key concepts: sentience, unnecessary suffering, and respect, which we examine in relation to the change in welfare legislation on the killing of fish and the handling and killing of fish before release. In the discussion (Section VI), we interpret these findings through our sociological and animal ethics framework, critically evaluating the inconsistencies in the legislation before offering our concluding remarks (Section VII).

II. Fishing: Fish Welfare, Societal Views, and Ethics

The Panel for Animal Health and Welfare of the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) has highlighted that the concept of animal welfare applies equally to all animals, including fish. [32] Defining animal welfare in terms of the experience of the animal itself is widely accepted by the scientific community and is understood as ‘the balance of positive and negative experiences over time’.[33] Sentience, in turn, refers to the capacity to experience both negative emotions, such as pain and fear, and positive emotions, such as pleasure and comfort.[34] The EFSA panel has concluded that the balance of evidence suggests a capacity for pain experience in some fish species and that reactions observed in fish indicate an ability to experience fear.[35] The need to produce a scientific opinion to inform policy on the capacity for pain and fear in fish indicates that fish are perceived differently from mammals and birds.

Fish encompass a vast and highly diverse group of vertebrates, comprising three major biological groups and an estimated 32,500 species, of which only a small number have been studied in detail.[36] The nociceptive system of bony fish and its neurophysiological basis are comparable to those of mammals, and fish show physiological and behavioural changes in response to noxious stimuli, which are reduced with analgesic use.[37] They also demonstrate motivation to avoid areas associated with painful experiences and are willing to incur costs to access analgesia.[38] Research also suggests that fish can experience stress and other negative emotions, such as negative anticipation of a startling event.[39] Even though the scientific community is more polarised when it comes to other aspects of fish sentience, Fernö et al., summarising the current literature, recently stated that it is ‘reasonable to believe that fish are conscious and have emotions and feelings’.[40] In turn, Franks et al. reviewed evidence of play behaviour and social affiliation in fish, both phenomena commonly linked to pleasure in mammals.[41] Due to the lack of research, uncertainty, however, remains regarding the extent and variation of emotional capacities across fish species.

Studies on public perceptions of the mental capacities of fish generally suggest that while people tend to consider them capable of pain and suffering, they are less likely to credit fish with other emotional or cognitive abilities.[42] For instance, in an international survey of the general public across 14 culturally diverse countries spanning six continents, 78 per cent of respondents believed that fish could feel pain, whereas a smaller proportion (61.5%) deemed them capable of feeling other emotions.[43] Generally, people attribute significantly higher emotional and cognitive capacities to mammals and birds than to phylogenetically more distant vertebrates, such as fish, reptiles, and amphibians.[44] Dietary practices are linked to mind attribution: pescatarians attribute lower mental capacities to aquatic species relative to terrestrial farmed animals in comparison to other dietary groups (including omnivores, vegetarians, and vegans).[45]

As regards attitudes in Finland, a population survey from 2010 shows that while the majority of Finns believe that fish can feel pain, only a small minority attribute more complex mental capacities to them.[46] These perceptions are closely connected to the cultural and societal context of fishing in Finnish society. Finland exhibits one of the highest participation rates in recreational fishing worldwide, popular among all age groups, and supported by abundant lakes, rivers, and coastline, where pole fishing with one pole is a common fishing right and free of charge for everyone.[47] Fish are centrally perceived as a food resource, exemplified by the common saying ‘the grain of the waters’ (‘vetten viljaa’), which not only constructs fish as food but likens them to plants and therefore positions them as insentient. Finnish fishing is rooted in subsistence fishing, with self-caught fish serving as an important component of people’s diet and with virtually all fish species found in Finland considered edible at the beginning of the 20th century.[48] Reflecting the recreational values associated with fishing today, a survey of Finnish anglers suggests that closeness to nature, the beauty of landscapes, relaxation, and the ability to forget worries are the most important factors associated with fishing for the majority of anglers.[49] Sport fishing is a type of recreational fishing where the competitive aspects of fishing are emphasised.[50] Fishing competitions are popular in Finland; in a survey of anglers who had paid the fisheries management fee, one in five reported having participated in a fishing competition during the past 12 months.[51]

Sustainability and conservation questions have been a central feature of Finnish discussions on fishing. In Finland, 29 per cent of fish taxa, largely migratory salmonid fish, are threatened or near threatened, with typical factors for their endangerment including water construction, deterioration of water quality, and overfishing.[52] However, only four taxa from Finland's approximately 70 fish species are protected from fishing year-round, their protection being regulated in fishing legislation.[53] This contrasts with other vertebrates, as most mammals and birds, and all amphibians and reptiles, are protected by the Nature Conservation Act (9/2023). With a renewal of the fishing legislation in 2014, Finland has aimed to improve the sustainability of fishing and to move from stocking-centred to regulation-based fisheries management, as well as to promote the natural reproduction of fish.[54]

The fishing process poses multiple welfare challenges to fish. Capture, retrieval, handling, and either killing or release involve stressors such as hypoxia, injury, exhaustion, and air exposure, with a cumulative negative impact on fish during the process.[55] The severity of these impacts varies by fishing method; for example, with gillnets, fish can suffer from skin and scale injuries, hypoxia, and exhaustion, while angling involves hooking injuries in the mouth area and exhaustion associated with long retrieval times and prolonged struggle.[56] If taken as catch, the slaughtering method impacts welfare. Humane slaughter involves stunning prior to killing, rendering the animal instantly unconscious and insensible to pain, followed by bleeding to ensure death without the animal regaining consciousness during the process.[57] In recreational fishing, effective percussive stunning and brain spiking, followed by immediate bleeding, are considered humane, while some anglers may still employ inhumane methods, including exsanguination without prior stunning and asphyxiation.[58] In the Finnish context, there has been an ongoing debate regarding the killing of fish in fishing competitions, as some participants have left their catch to die by asphyxiation, while the organisers have not enforced the use of humane slaughter in the events, resulting in the need for animal welfare authorities to intervene based on the requirements of the Animal Protection Act (247/1996).[59] Commercial fisheries often fail to meet humane slaughter standards, and fish die by asphyxiation or by exsanguination or evisceration while conscious.[60]

Although public attitudes toward farmed fish welfare have been investigated to some extent across cultures, there is limited empirical research on public attitudes toward fish welfare in recreational fishing.[61] A survey of the New Zealand general public found that most respondents believed fish were capable of feeling pain, and that catch-and-release (henceforth C&R) fishing caused pain and reduced survival.[62] Nonetheless, the majority still found C&R fishing acceptable.[63] Another survey of educated citizens in Brazil found that a large majority considered fish capable of feeling emotions, with most considering that fish suffered when removed from the water.[64]] Only one-fifth of these respondents considered C&R fishing to be acceptable, and hook-and-line fishing was rated as causing high levels of suffering.[65] Furthermore, while most had not previously heard of humane slaughter, a large majority supported extending humane slaughter regulations to fish.[66]

In Finland, the idea of using caught fish as food has been a fundamental aspect of the fishing tradition.[67] However, in today’s recreational fishing, fish can be released after capture due to legal requirements or the angler’s voluntary decision. C&R fishing, where catch-sized fish are released voluntarily, began to emerge in Finland in the 1990s.[68] Voluntary release of all the catch is a minority practice, reported by 4–8 per cent of anglers, while 30 per cent report the occasional release of some of their catch.[69] Reasons for release include the caught fish not conforming to the species or size desired by the angler, the angler seeking to conserve fish stocks, or the angler’s desire for experiences from fishing other than the acquisition of food. [70]

Released fish experience pain and stress from the capture process, along with potential injuries and stress post-release.[71] They can suffer sublethal injuries to the mouth, jaw, throat, or oesophagus from the hook and its removal, as well as scale loss, mucous layer damage, and fin abrasions from landing nets and handling.[72] These injuries may cause pain and affect behaviour, making fish more vulnerable to predation and reducing their feeding after release.[73] Acute stress related to hooking and retrieval can lead to physiological disturbances, resulting in weakened immune responses and reproductive failure.[74] C&R fishing also carries a risk of post-release mortality due to physical injuries and the combined effects of multiple stressors involved in the fishing process, which may cause pain and prolonged suffering, especially with delayed mortality.[75] Negative impacts can be mitigated by modifying fishing practices to minimise the likelihood of catching unwanted or prohibited fish.[76]

C&R fishing has been a controversial practice since its emergence in Finland, with public debates labelling it a foreign import that does not belong to traditional Finnish fishing culture.[77] Critics argue that it represents alienation from nature, animal torture, and the objectification of fish as toys, while supporters defend it on the grounds of sustaining fish stocks and ensuring natural reproduction.[78] A national survey found that 60 per cent of recreational anglers viewed C&R as unnecessary harassment of fish, while a more recent small-scale survey revealed mixed opinions: some anglers see it as an unnecessary stressor, while others view it as a means of conserving fish stocks.[79] In turn, a small-scale survey of water body owners revealed negative perspectives on C&R; it was generally not considered an effective method for protecting endangered trout stocks, and some criticised the practice as a form of amusement derived from the suffering of fish, while others called for better regulations regarding fish handling and gear.[80] Small-scale angler and water body owner surveys also suggest that the majority support practices that promote fish welfare, including the use of barbless hooks, the reduction of air exposure, and the limiting of fishing when the water is too warm.[81]

Given the differing knowledge levels regarding fish capacities and welfare, as well as the divergent views and perceptions of what constitutes sustainable and responsible fishing methods, a number of ethical issues emerge.[82] In this article, we focus our ethical reflection on the role of legislators in mirroring public perception while acknowledging its variety. We will show how the diverging views regarding scientific facts on fish capacities lead to epistemological challenges for lawmakers and further discuss how to perceive the ethical responsibility of the individual angler in a fishing community that doubts the scientific facts regarding fish sentience. Here, we will use not only ethical concepts related to the object – the fish – such as respect, but also concepts related to fundamental ethical principles, such as the benefit of the doubt. One overall challenge in the ethical consideration of fish relates to the perceived inherent silence of fish and our tendency to overlook their capacity to be agents. In this article, we will suggest that this might be due to our own lack of competence in intuitively understanding them. In this context, the concept of shared vulnerability becomes relevant and will be used to deepen the ethical reflection on the epistemological challenge regarding sentience.

III. National Legal Framework: Wild Fish Welfare and Finnish Animal Welfare Law

The Animal Welfare Act (693/2023) (henceforth AWA) constitutes the central framework law governing the treatment of all non-human animals in Finland, both domesticated and wild. The AWA came into force on 1 January 2024, replacing the Animal Protection Act (247/1996) (henceforth APA) and the Animal Protection Decree (396/1996).[83] In addition to the AWA, animal welfare norms have been included in various specific pieces of legislation; in the context of fishing, the most central law is the Fishing Act (379/2015).[84]

The purpose, scope, and central provisions of the acts relevant to this article are included in the Appendix A. In the new AWA, the promotion of welfare is the primary objective, which is also reflected in the name of the act. In addition, the AWA contains a new aim of increasing respect for animals. Although most of the provisions in the AWA regulate the keeping, care, and treatment of animals under human care, general principles, general requirements on treatment, prohibited treatment, and general requirements on killing also apply to wild animals.[85] Additionally, certain provisions specifically concern the welfare of wild animals, such as provisions on wild animal care and euthanasia, and prohibitions on capturing wild animals to be cared for.[86] As a new rule, the prohibition on killing animals for entertainment purposes was included in the AWA, based on the objective of increasing respect for animals; however, killing animals in fishing was demarcated outside the ban.[87]

Finnish animal welfare law represents legal welfarism, where the aim of protection is the welfare of an individual animal.[88] The principle of avoidance of suffering is a leading legal principle, and the prohibition on causing unnecessary suffering has been codified in animal protection acts since 1934.[89] Hence, causing suffering is permitted when it is deemed ‘necessary’ based on weighing harms against benefits, where human benefit is considered in relation to the harm caused to the animal.[90] The principle of avoidance of suffering manifests the sentientistic character of legal welfarism: its object of protection is sentient animals capable of experiencing negative and positive emotions.[91] Sentientism characterises Finnish animal welfare law markedly: although the animal welfare acts from 1996 and 2023 apply to all animals, in reality, their application concerns sentient animals who are capable of feeling pain and suffering.[92]

By contrast, the Fishing Act (379/2015) is primarily oriented toward the management and use of fish as natural resources, applying to the fishing and catching of fish, lamperns, and crayfish.[93] The Act regulates fishing rights and methods, the management of fish stocks, and the duties of fishery organisations. Unlike the AWA and the Hunting Act (615/1993), the Fishing Act does not include any general prohibition on causing unnecessary suffering to fish.[94] Nor does the Government Bill for the Fishing Act (192/2014) mention the sentience of fish or express any objectives to protect their welfare in fishing practices. Rather, the objective of the Fishing Act is to organise the sustainable use of fish resources with the aim of securing their sustainable and diversified return, the natural life cycle of fish stocks, as well as the diversity and protection of fish resources and other aquatic nature (see Appendix A).[95] As the objective indicates, fish are approached as resources in the Fishing Act: they are living resources as components of biodiversity, as well as a common natural resource that is managed and used for the purposes of recreational and commercial fishing.[96]

Nevertheless, the Fishing Act contains provisions that are relevant from a fish welfare perspective. The act, for instance, prohibits the use of explosives, firearms, toxic substances, electricity, and the intentional hooking of fish from outside.[97] Additionally, equipment and ways of fishing that ‘unnecessarily damage fish’ are prohibited.[98] Although these prohibitions stem from the objective of protecting fish stocks and the aquatic environment, the reference to ‘unnecessary damage’ allows for the prohibition of equipment and methods that damage individual fish, not just those that affect fish as part of the stock.[99] However, because this damage can be understood to refer only to physical injuries without encompassing the mental aspect of suffering, we suggest that this prohibition does not clearly reflect the principle of avoidance of suffering. By lacking a codification of the avoidance of suffering and the concept of sentience, the Fishing Act is only weakly connected to the central principles and concepts of Finnish animal welfare law.

The Fishing Act includes provisions for the protection of fish either entirely or in certain areas and time frames, as well as regulations on catch sizes.[100] Catching and selling protected fish is prohibited.[101] Fish must be released immediately if they are not within the regulated catch size limits or if they are caught during a closed or prohibited season, or with prohibited fishing equipment or methods.[102] This mandatory release of fish is based on the poor selectivity of fishing methods, which leads to the risk of the unintentional capture of prohibited fish.[103] Although these provisions pursue a conservation objective and aim to maintain fishing at a sustainable level, they hold implications for the welfare of fish because they protect certain fish from being caught in the first place,[104] and, if caught, the release of the fish incurs welfare consequences, such as handling and potential post-release injuries and stress.

As part of the preparation of the AWA, the section on the release of fish in the Fishing Act was amended to include a new requirement to treat fish carefully and to kill obviously injured fish before returning them to the water.[105] Furthermore, the Fishing Act was amended to include new provisions concerning the killing of fish that are similar in content to the general requirements for animal killing in the AWA (see Appendix A).[106] These provisions mandate that fish must be killed as quickly and painlessly as possible, with pre-stunning required if the method of killing does not result in immediate death. While the use of live fish as bait was prohibited, large catches were exempted from the immediate killing requirement. These new provisions are norms of animal welfare law that were included in the fishing legislation.[107]

Apart from the above-mentioned regulations, there are very few binding provisions regarding the protection of fish welfare in fishing. For instance, the Fishing Act does not include any detailed regulations on the frequency of inspecting gillnets and fish cages, the temperature limits for fishing, the exposure of fish to air and its duration, the use of gaffs and other landing equipment, and the handling of fish. However, there may be local restrictions on fishing that can impact fish welfare, as the owners of a water area are entitled to govern fishing in their waters,[108] and a regional fishing authority can impose restrictions, such as prohibiting certain fishing gear, if the viability or return of a fish stock is degraded or at risk of degradation.[109]

IV. Material and Methods

The first set of materials we examine consists of the Government Proposal to Parliament for an Act on Animal Welfare and Related Acts (Bill 186/2022), along with its draft version submitted for public consultation.[110] Bill 186/2022 was prepared by the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry (MAF) over a period of more than 10 years. We analyse legislators’ intentions, reasoning, and definitions of the concepts by focusing on the detailed motivations behind the objectives (section 1) and general principles (section 6) of the AWA, as well as the motivations for the proposed new provisions in the Fishing Act concerning the handling and killing of fish before release (section 58(3)) and the killing of fish caught or used as bait (section 58 a) (the contents of the sections can be found in Appendix A).

Secondly, we examine the arguments presented by stakeholder organisations in their comments on the draft bill during a consultation period from 4 November 2021 to 14 January 2022. We chose to analyse only the comments from stakeholder organisations, as they represent the collective interests or expert positions of groups involved in policymaking – such as actors from civil society, public authorities, research, and various professions – rather than the individual views of citizens. The MAF received 160 comments from stakeholder organisations and published all of them, along with a summary, on its website.[111] The MAF also compiled all stakeholder organisations’ comments into a separate document where each organisation’s comment was available section by section.[112] In this document, we analysed all stakeholder comments that the MAF had compiled under the section on the amendment of the Fishing Act. Additionally, we analysed comments concerning wild fish welfare in fishing in stakeholder organisations’ general comments on the draft bill and the AWA. A word search was used to identify extracts that concerned fish.[113] The treatment and killing of wild fish in fishing were commented on in 40 submissions by 41 stakeholder organisations, including 33 submissions commenting on the amendment of the Fishing Act (Appendix B). These organisations included groups representing recreational and professional fishers, animal advocacy, and research, alongside veterinarians, animal welfare control officials, and fishery authorities (Table 1).[114]

Table 1. Stakeholder Comments on Wild Fish Welfare Provisions in Draft Bill 186/2022.

The table summarises the comments of organisations analysed in the study, grouped by category.

We conducted a qualitative thematic analysis of the legislative documents and stakeholder submissions. The analysis and interpretation followed an iterative process that involved setting the research problem, familiarising ourselves with the material, and closely reading and analysing the texts. The first stage of data familiarisation involved a research assistant compiling observations on internal and external contradictions in Bill 186/2022 and the justifications provided for them. Following this, we decided to focus more closely on fish. The research problem was discussed and clarified in team meetings involving all co-authors, and more thoroughly evaluated between the first and fourth authors.

The textual analysis involved reading the material closely several times, coding the stakeholder comments using the qualitative analysis software ATLAS.ti (version 26), and deepening our interpretation by relating the material to the theoretical literature. Coding the stakeholder comments assisted our analysis by helping us track extracts that addressed specific themes, allowing us to revisit and re-read the arguments related to those themes. The final coding list included four code groups: fish sentience, release of fish, killing of fish, and fishing competitions and recreational fishing. In the analysis of the documents, we paid close attention to the concepts and terminology used in the arguments and their underlying reasoning. We examined recurring themes and argumentative patterns across the comments, while also noting what was missing in the lines of argumentation. We compared the positions articulated by different actor groups to map the landscape of the debate. Particular attention was paid to identifying the underlying justifications, value claims, and points of contradiction within and between the legislative text and stakeholder arguments. In the parts we analysed, the final Bill 186/2022 did not differ significantly from the draft bill. Where the content is the same, we refer to both the draft and the final bill. We also pinpoint parts where the final bill differed from the draft bill. Quotes from the bill, the draft bill, and stakeholder comments have been translated from Finnish into English by the authors.[115]

V. Analysis

This section examines how the concepts of sentience, unnecessary suffering, and respect are constructed in the government proposal and stakeholder comments. After analysing the sentientistic approach in the AWA and discussing fish sentience, we explore the notion of unnecessary suffering through a discussion on releasing, handling, and killing fish. We also analyse how the concept of respect is negotiated, particularly in the context of fishing competitions and the prohibition on killing for entertainment.

1. Construction of Fish Sentience

In the AWA, the promotion of animal welfare and increasing respect are anchored in the sentience and subjective experience of animals. Animal welfare is defined explicitly in the act as ‘an animal's experience of its own physical and mental state’, reflecting the common approach in animal welfare science.[116] Pain is defined in the detailed motivation as ‘both the physical sensation of pain and the psychological feeling that is caused by it’, and suffering, in turn, refers to ‘an unpleasant feeling or sensation, such as distress, fear, anxiety, and frustration’.[117] Therefore, in the context of the AWA, the welfare of fish is understood in terms of subjective experience. It is not explicitly stated which species are considered sentient and capable of mental experiences. However, the new provisions in the Fishing Act are motivated by the objective of preventing ‘unnecessary pain and suffering’ in fish, thereby acknowledging that fish can feel pain and suffer.[118]

In most stakeholder comments, the capacity of fish to feel pain and suffer was taken for granted, without the need to explicitly endorse this capacity or provide evidence for it. This was evident in the references to how certain practices inflict suffering on fish, as well as in the emphasis on avoiding and minimising their suffering. However, some stakeholders, including animal advocacy organisations, research organisations, and public authorities, explicitly endorsed the capacity of fish to feel pain. In some of the statements, this was regarded as proven, state-of-the-art knowledge: ‘The Ministry of the Environment particularly welcomes the inclusion of fish and crayfish in the new act, as it is known that both fish and crayfish feel pain’ (Ministry of the Environment). Other stakeholders referred to research in general or to certain research publications that provide evidence for fish sentience, using it as an argument for the demand for better protection of fish. ‘So much is known about the capacity of fish to suffer that the threat of slow death by suffocation or crushing billions of individuals is no longer acceptable today,’ stated Justice for Animals. The Faculty of Veterinary Medicine at the University of Helsinki noted that, ‘According to the latest research, pain perception in fish does not significantly differ from that of mammals. The experience of pain in fish is not a mere reflexive mechanical reaction. For example, fish learn to avoid places where they have experienced pain.’

By contrast, some of the statements expressed doubt about fish sentience. This viewpoint was held by fisheries authorities and recreational fishing organisations, who argued that there was no scientific consensus on the consciousness of fish. The inclusion of the concepts of pain and suffering in the detailed motivation for the amendment of the Fishing Act was considered problematic. Defining pain as a psychological phenomenon appeared challenging, as did the use of the term ‘suffering’ in reference to fish. The stakeholders considered the term ‘stress’ more appropriate when referring to fish. Indeed, acute stress responses in fish can be assessed using physiological indicators and do not, in themselves, require assumptions about subjective experience.[119]

  • In the detailed explanatory memorandum to the proposed Section 58(3), the terms pain and suffering are used. In the case of fish, the use of the terms pain and especially suffering is not unambiguously correct based on existing knowledge. Studies that have reported indications of conscious pain experience in fish have been critically reviewed for their methodology and, on the other hand, for over- or misinterpretation of results. In addition, some of these studies have not been possible to replicate (Browman et al., 2019). Thus, it would be justified to consistently use the word stress instead of pain and suffering. (Fisheries Authority of the Lapland Centre for Economic Development, Transport and the Environment)[120]

‘[T]here is no scientific consensus on the degree to which fish feel pain,’ argued the Recreational Fishers’ Association of Central Finland. The Finnish Federation for Recreational Fishing (SVK) highlighted the definition of suffering in the explanatory memorandum and questioned the ability of fish to suffer and to experience pain as a psychological phenomenon:

  • [T]here is no conclusive scientific evidence of suffering in fish and crayfish (for instance, Browman et al. (...) 2019, ICES Journal of Marine Science). Fish are known to experience pain (it is necessary for self-protection), but this is different from the conscious feeling of pain (= suffering). The SVK suggests that proposals directly concerning fish and crabs should only talk about avoiding unnecessary pain and stress. It should also be noted that the bill’s definition of pain in relation to fish is not fully scientifically justifiable, since the bill would define pain as both the physical sensation of pain and the psychological feeling caused by it. (Finnish Federation for Recreational Fishing)[121]

Questioning the capacity of fish to feel pain and suffer was related to the actors’ opposition to some of the welfare provisions proposed to protect fish (see below). These actors neither demanded more research on fish sentience nor emphasised the need for precautionary measures. Hence, it appeared that they cast doubt on the capacities of fish to challenge the proposed fish welfare provisions.

2. Release of Fish

In the AWA, the object of protection is the welfare of sentient animals, and a foundational aim is to protect animals from impaired welfare. The detailed motivation of Bill 186/2022 acknowledges that it is not always possible to avoid harm when people exploit animals.[122] The bill endorses harm-benefit analysis, highlighting the importance of ‘an ethical consideration concerning what kind of harm is acceptable in relation to the benefits of keeping and using animals.’[123] Here, one should consider ‘prevailing social and economic conditions.’[124] It is further explained that ‘an animal could still be subjected to pain and suffering as long as there is an acceptable reason.’[125] In the following analysis, we examine how the necessity of fish suffering was constructed in the bill and in the stakeholder comments in relation to the release and killing of fish.

The draft bill included a new requirement that a fish intended to be released back into the water must be handled as carefully as possible but killed if ‘in such a state that it has no chance of surviving’.[126] This was motivated by the objective of reducing unnecessary suffering.[127] This provision meant that in situations where the release of the fish was mandatory, release would depend on the fish’s physical condition: if signs implying a high risk of the fish dying, including ‘external injuries, blood loss, immobility, or lack of breathing reflexes’, were present, the angler would have a duty to kill the fish.[128]

It is hereby evident that legislators hold the view that releasing injured fish that are unlikely to survive comprises unnecessary suffering, whereas injuries assessed as sublethal constitute permitted suffering. The chance of survival functions as a threshold for the decision to kill rather than the level of assessed suffering or the welfare of the fish. Hence, the detailed motivation includes examples of signs that can indicate mortal wounds but no description of injuries (such as the severity of hooking injuries) that would form the basis for euthanising the fish for welfare reasons. It appears that the fish is allowed to experience even severe suffering if it is considered likely to survive. This reasoning is logical when fish are mainly seen as a resource and survival is viewed at a species or biomass level.

The proposal received contradictory comments from stakeholder organisations. The first line of argumentation, put forward by the regional fisheries authorities and the Finnish Federation for Recreational Fishing, emphasised the extreme difficulty of assessing the fish’s chance of survival based on external factors and anglers’ lack of ability to make an appropriate viability assessment. The stakeholders were concerned that this may result in the unnecessary killing of fish that could have survived the catch.

  • The likelihood of a fish surviving once it has been released after capture is very difficult to assess. A fish that appears to have been badly injured by the catch may survive and live for a long time after being released back into the water. (…) An ambiguous interpretation of the legislation leads to unnecessary killing of protected fish and fish whose deliberate capture is prohibited, which is not in line with the objectives of the Fishing Act. (Fisheries Unit of the North-Savo Centre for Economic Development, Transport and the Environment)

The Finnish Federation for Recreational Fishing considered that killing those fish that would have survived the catch would be ‘particularly dangerous for endangered migratory fish and rarely occurring large brood fish’. The Fisheries Authority of the Lapland Centre for Economic Development, Transport and the Environment pointed out that the killing of fish that would have survived the catch would be ‘unsustainable from the biodiversity perspective’, arguing that ‘[i]f implemented as proposed, this provision would likely water down the objectives of the Fishing Act’.

The actors suggested that the obligation should be removed from the bill, or, if included, that it should, at least, contain an exemption for those fish mandated to be released to secure the viability of endangered or threatened fish species. According to the view presented, these fish should always be released, regardless of their condition, because the ordinary angler could not assess their survival potential. The Finnish Federation for Recreational Fishing suggested that instead of regulatory measures, the focus should be on advisory measures directed at anglers to promote ‘the successful release of fish’. Hence, the objectives of preserving biodiversity and conserving endangered fish served as benefits that were weighted higher than limiting the harm to an individual injured fish. In addition, as the capacity of fish to suffer was doubted, the harm to fish appeared to be potential stress rather than pain and suffering.

The second line of argumentation was grounded in the suffering and welfare of fish. The criteria regarding the obligation to kill injured fish before returning them to the water and the angler’s ability to make that assessment were criticised from an animal welfare perspective. The Faculty of Veterinary Medicine noted that ‘It is also problematic that the fish’s potential survival is left to the fisherperson to judge. There is a risk that animals that are significantly injured will be returned to the water.’ The Regional State Administrative Agency for Eastern Finland suggested a stricter formulation of the provision: ‘only fish that are clearly intact or only very slightly injured can be released alive’, highlighting that the detailed motivation should include more examples of situations when releasing the fish alive was still acceptable.

In the critical arguments concerning voluntary C&R presented by animal advocacy organisations, some research organisations, and animal welfare authorities, the argument was anchored in ‘entertainment’, ‘competitions’, ‘amusement’, and ‘thrill’ as aspects of human benefit. The acceptability of causing suffering to fish as part of C&R for entertainment was questioned, or it was clearly stated that this form of fishing should be forbidden in the new legislation. Arguments were mainly grounded in the suffering of fish, but the notion of respectful treatment was also raised.

  • It should be added to the section [of the Fishing Act] that catch-and-release fishing is prohibited. This means that fish may not be caught solely for the purpose of competition and measurement. (Animalia, animal rights NGO)

Some organisations commented on voluntary C&R fishing in light of the general principles (s 6) and prohibited treatment (s 13) in the AWA. The AWA prohibits rough handling or other treatment of an animal in a manner that causes unnecessary pain and suffering; in addition, it is forbidden to subject it to excessive strain or unnecessary injury (see Appendix A). In the arguments presented, C&R for entertainment was perceived as contradictory to the general principles of the AWA and a form of prohibited treatment.

  • Could Catch-and-Release fishing be considered prohibited under this section [section 6 on general principles]? Fishing for thrill and excitement, to set a record or to compete on the basis of the size of the fish is not respectful of the animal and should be considered an animal’s use for entertainment. It also causes unnecessary pain and suffering and unnecessarily endangers welfare. (Regional State Administrative Agency for Southwestern Finland)

The provision and its motivation changed somewhat after the comments round. Both Bill 186/2022 and the final act required that if a fish intended to be released was ‘obviously injured’, it must be killed before being returned to the water.[129]

In the bill, this was explained as follows,

  • If the fish to be released is clearly so injured that it is likely to die after release, the fish should be killed before returning to the water to reduce unnecessary suffering. Examples of clear injuries likely to result in the death of the fish would include major bleeding or immobility of the fish when touched.[130]

In other words, the formulation was changed so that the viability assessment was less ambiguous. The angler’s duty to kill fish assessed to be mortally wounded was retained. Comments concerning the acceptability of C&R for entertainment in light of the general principles and prohibited treatment outlined in the AWA were not considered in the final bill.

3. Killing of Fish

This section examines how unnecessary suffering and respect were negotiated in relation to the killing of fish as part of fishing. The amendment to the Fishing Act included new provisions on the killing of fish taken as catch or used as bait, containing provisions similar to the AWA’s general requirements on killing (see Appendix A). Although humane killing had already been required for fishing under the APA, the regulation was clarified by amending the Fishing Act. The aim was to address the treatment of fish and to harmonise the rules on their killing with animal welfare legislation, with a specific emphasis on the application of these rules to fishing competitions.[131]

Additionally, as a new requirement, killing animals for entertainment purposes was prohibited in the AWA. The ban was linked to the law’s novel purpose to increase respect for animals.[132] The claim for respect is based on the idea of the intrinsic value of animals – a concept described in the motivation text of Bill 186/2022 but not mentioned in the act itself. This intrinsic value refers to an animal’s ‘moral status’ as ‘a sentient being that has physical and psychological needs and an ability to experience positive and negative emotions.’[133] Intrinsic value is the opposite of instrumental value and demands that an animal ‘should be respected as an animal and for its own sake.’[134] The bill explains that respect is enacted mainly through actions that promote welfare, but it also involves the ethical consideration of how animals should be treated.[135] It is stated that ‘actions that do not directly harm the welfare of an animal but are perceived as degrading the value of the animal may be incompatible with respect for animals.’[136] There is, however, no mention of respect for individual fish in either the bill or the Fishing Act.

The duty to treat animals with respect in the AWA includes the idea of protecting and respecting an animal’s life. Killing animals is permitted, but it requires ‘an acceptable reason’.[137]

This is explained in the detailed motivation of the general principles:

  • Nor should the provision [section 6] be interpreted as protecting the life of an animal as such and thus preventing the killing of an animal for an acceptable reason. The life of an animal should be respected, but respect for animals should not prevent humans from ending an animal’s life as needed.[138]

Bill 186/2022 specifies that killing animals for entertainment is not an acceptable reason;[139] in other words, it is forbidden despite potential societal acceptance. Killing for entertainment refers to ‘performances or competitions where the purpose of killing an animal is specifically to create entertainment or a cultural experience for the public.’[140] Such prohibited activities include, for example, ‘competitions to see who can kill the most animals in a given period of time, or entertainment or cultural performances where an animal is killed for purposes of amusement.’[141] It is noteworthy that the bill emphasises, without any further justification, that killing animals during hunting or fishing is not considered killing for entertainment, and, therefore, fishing competitions are still permitted,[142] combined with the obligation for the immediate and appropriate killing of the catch.

Most stakeholders were in favour of adding new provisions on the killing of fish to the Fishing Act, which is familiar to anglers and therefore suitable legislation to promote more humane practices among them. Furthermore, as there had been cases where the APA’s requirements for the immediate killing of the catch in fishing competitions had not been followed, regulating the matter in the Fishing Act was regarded as a relevant clarification. For instance, the Regional State Administrative Agency for Lapland considered ‘the proposal to amend the Fishing Act on the killing of fish to be very necessary and the only way to change the treatment of catches in various fishing competitions.’

A minority view, held by recreational fishers’ organisations, criticised the proposed requirements and demanded that the killing obligation should not be applied to fishing competitions or to those forms of competition where small fish are caught in large numbers. The reasoning was based on the view that the new requirements would hinder fishing competitions and reduce the attractiveness of fishing as a nature-based recreation:

  • Fishing is a great nature hobby, and those who are most active and who promote the hobby the most are the ones who especially take part in competitions. The proposed change to the killing obligation will reduce the number of people participating in competitions. In our opinion, such things that make the hobby more difficult will steer people, and especially young people, further away from fine nature hobbies. (Recreational fishers of Kainuu)

Additionally, catching large numbers of small fish was considered management fishing, which the new requirement would make more difficult: ‘The immediate killing of fish, as proposed in the draft, slows down and complicates angling, where it is often attempted to catch as many small fish as possible, either for management or public utility purposes’ (Recreational Fishers’ Association of Central Finland). The Federation of Finnish Fisheries Associations and the Recreational Fishers’ Association of Central Finland held the view that it should not be necessary to kill fish immediately if the purpose of fishing, regardless of the method used, was to catch a large number of small fish, or if safe killing was challenging, or if the expected food quality of the fish was compromised by the method of killing.

We identified a contrasting argument, put forward by animal advocacy organisations, in which fishing competitions were constructed as a form of using animals for entertainment. It was argued that the prohibition on killing for entertainment in the AWA should also cover fishing competitions where participants compete on the size of the catch, which appeared contradictory to the AWA’s requirement to treat animals with respect. It was highlighted that in fishing and hunting competitions, animals are killed as a form of entertainment and that killing wild animals for entertainment is no more ethically acceptable than killing domestic animals for the same reason.

  • The general compliance with the Animal Protection Act or the new Animal Welfare Act in society is effectively promoted when members of society have a healthy, respectful attitude towards animals. Animal killing competitions tend to blur the formation of a proper relationship with animals. Such competitions, which primarily serve as entertainment for humans, should be prohibited by law. (Animalia’s regional branch in the Helsinki Metropolitan Area)

In its comment on the AWA’s requirement to treat animals with respect, the Regional State Administrative Agency for Southwestern Finland suggested, ‘In fishing competitions, fishing should also have objectives (e.g. use of the catch for food) beyond the maximum possible catch.’ In the comments, therefore, killing an animal for the sole purpose of competition was not an acceptable reason for taking an animal’s life and was against the principle of respect included in the new AWA.

The bill proposed that immediate killing was not required ‘if the catch is so large that killing them all at once is practically impossible.’[143] According to the rationale, large catches can be obtained, for example, from trawling, seining, and trap fishing, or fishing with gillnets or fish traps for vendace, smelt, herring, or sprat.[144] Most of the stakeholders criticised the exception to immediate killing for large catches, whereas the Finnish Association of Professional Fishers and the Federation of Finnish Fisheries Associations found the legislative changes properly justified.

Critical stakeholders first highlighted a notable contradiction in the bill: despite the general objective of promoting animal welfare in the AWA, the new legislation demanded the humane killing of a small number of individual fish, while harm to a larger number of individuals was permitted. It was noted that, as a result, most of the fish were exempt from the new requirement, and a slow death by asphyxiation was still permitted.

  • There is a clear contradiction in the draft law: a small catch must be killed immediately, but a large catch taken at once is allowed to die by suffocation. From an animal welfare point of view, it is not right that fish, even the same species of fish, are treated differently in different situations. (Natural Resources Institute Finland)

The Finnish Federation of Recreational Fishing and the Fisheries Authority of the Lapland Centre for Economic Development, Transport and the Environment pointed out that the humane killing requirement concerned only a minuscule portion of the annual catch. The Finnish Federation of Recreational Fishing held the view that applying the obligation only to small catches and certain types of fishing was unfair and undermined the general acceptability of the law:

  • With the current provisions, the impact of the Animal Welfare Act on fisheries can be estimated to be applicable to a couple of per cent of all fish caught. When animal welfare is at stake, the killing obligation must apply in principle to all fishing, regardless of the type of fishing, whether the catches are large or small. (The Finnish Federation of Recreational Fishing)

Many stakeholders, including animal advocacy organisations, political parties, researchers, and the Finnish Association for Surveillance Veterinarians, opposed the exception or required a transition period for humane slaughter in large-scale fishing. Additionally, some stakeholders, such as Natural Resources Institute Finland and the Finnish Centre for Animal Welfare, called for research on and development of mass stunning and killing methods.

Neither the provisions on killing for entertainment in the AWA nor the requirements for killing fish in the amendment of the Fishing Act, or their motivation in the bill, were changed in response to the critical comments.[145] The requirement to practice immediate killing in fishing competitions was retained, but fishing competitions remained permitted without any further regulation despite the new requirement for respectful treatment in the AWA. In the pre-work material, legislators did not express any objective to promote the introduction of humane slaughter in large-scale fishing, revealing a standpoint closer to stakeholders from the commercial fishing industry than to researchers and animal welfare organisations.

VI. Discussion

This article has examined the reasoning in the government proposal (186/2022) for Finland’s new animal welfare legislation and the arguments presented by stakeholder organisations regarding three core concepts: sentience, unnecessary suffering, and respect. We have scrutinised how these concepts were constructed in relation to the treatment of fish in fishing practices. In the following sections, we elaborate on their meaning and role for the implementation of legal thresholds, highlighting both epistemological challenges and inconsistencies in the reasoning. Finally, we discuss our findings within an ethical framework inspired by, but not exclusively limited to, Cora Diamond’s reflection on the human-animal relationship in terms of exposure and vulnerability.

1. Fish Sentience and the Moral Positioning of Fish

In the legislative amendment, animal welfare requirements concerning fish handling and killing were included in the Fishing Act based on the objective of protecting fish from unnecessary suffering. However, the addition of these animal welfare norms was not without problems, as the Fishing Act does not include the principle of avoidance of suffering in its framework provisions. Although most stakeholders either considered the capacity of fish to feel pain and suffer as self-evident or referred to evidence supporting it, fishing actors were critical of using such concepts in relation to fish, highlighting the lack of scientific consensus on fish sentience and expressing doubt about the validity of fish pain research. This suggests that there is no common ground regarding the scientific facts on which to base the value discussion. This reflects a wider societal perception in Finnish society, where citizens’ views on fish sentience are divided, and fish are ascribed lower mental capacities than mammals and birds.[146]

Recreational fishing organisations used their doubt about fish sentience to argue for less strict measures to promote fish welfare. This highlights a potential ‘Pandora’s Box’ in the realm of recreational fishing: acknowledging that fish had inner experiences and could feel pain could fundamentally change the perception of the practice. The de-mentalisation of animals, attributing diminished mental capacities to them, is connected to assigning them lower moral worth, making their use appear morally less bothersome.[147] Therefore, the inclusion of animal welfare requirements in the Fishing Act can be viewed as conceptually important: the explicit acknowledgement of fish pain and suffering in the amendment of the Fishing Act plays a role in shaping attitudes toward fish among anglers and other fishery actors.

The epistemological question of how knowledge is perceived and constructed, and the animal welfare science question of the level of sentience possessed by an animal, relate directly to each other in the moral discussion on how to treat animals. In the animal ethics literature, although the focus has mainly been on mammals, these issues are addressed along the lines of the ‘benefit of the doubt’: if there is a lack of solid science to prove a capacity (e.g. sentience), the weaker part of the equation (here, aquatic animals) shall be given the benefit of the doubt, that is, treated and considered as if they possessed this capacity.[148] The aim is to minimise the risk of a moral error by placing the cost on the side of the stronger part. Such an approach is perhaps even more relevant in the case of animal species we find difficult to understand, whose expressions of feelings and interests are challenging to interpret. In general, fish are regarded as lacking facial expressions and the ‘cute factor’, and they have no voice to express pain or fear in ways that are comprehensible to humans.[149] Due to this, fish are placed low on the sociozoological scale, a moral hierarchy based on the social classification of animals, and are often omitted from moral reasoning.[150]

While animal welfare legislation aims to protect the welfare of an individual animal, the focus of fishing legislation lies at the species and stock level. Hence, lawmakers open the door to a split perspective, or double standards, in how to handle fish. In summary, under Finnish law, wild fish can be understood to possess a dual status: on the one hand, they are sentient beings, as addressed in animal welfare legislation, but, on the other hand, they are regarded as a resource, albeit a living one, as described in fishing legislation.[151]

2. Necessary Suffering: Legislating Customary Practices

As shown in the analysis, lawmakers explicitly state that public acceptance of a certain practice in animal keeping and handling limits the scope of the revision of the new AWA. Hence, suffering considered customary and generally accepted in society was not open for discussion and was beforehand regarded as necessary. The legal scholar Veera Koponen interprets unnecessary suffering in Finnish animal welfare law as suffering that exceeds what is regarded as customary and essential in the use of animals at the time.[152] The accepted level is linked to the prevalent moral views in society; in this way, the content of what constitutes necessity is flexible, changing, and reflective of the societal values of the time, while the principle itself is sustained over time.[153] In animal law scholarship, this principle has been interpreted as inherently anthropocentric: human interests are assigned much higher weight than those of nonhuman animals, and even the severe and extensive suffering of nonhuman animals can be considered permissible for relatively minor human interests.[154]

However, the core purpose of the AWA is to promote animal welfare, and welfare impairments must be justified, which calls for a harm-benefit analysis of animal use to ensure that the harm inflicted on animals is proportionate to the benefit of their use. Given this possibility of a trade-off between human benefits and animal welfare, each situation of animal use is open to judgment, which in turn risks rendering the regulation relativistic. To a large extent, this balancing of harm and benefit is a subjective undertaking.[155] In animal experiments, the challenges related to stipulating and finding such a balance have been the subject of intense discussion.[156] In animal research, the elements of benefit can, to some degree, be assessed in terms of scientific validity and reliability – a more objective approach than what is possible for animal use in many other fields, such as the pleasure of eating a specific dish or animal use for entertainment. Regarding the other part of the equation, the harm inflicted on fish during angling and subsequent potential release, there is a higher chance of measuring it objectively. Although there might be variations between fish species, current research presents a general picture of what causes welfare hazards, such as hooking injuries, dry handling, handling above water, and poor water quality when kept in buckets.[157] However, due to doubts about the accuracy of fish pain research and the resulting low acceptance of scientific facts about fish capacities within influential parts of the fishing community, it is difficult to find a consensus on the only part of the harm-benefit analysis that is based on measurable dimensions.

Simultaneously, the detailed provisions point in a different direction to the general values expressed in the framework provisions of the AWA concerning the promotion of welfare and increasing respect for animals. This was particularly evident in the provision on the killing of injured fish before release: the yardstick was not the level of suffering in fish but the likelihood of survival from a resource perspective, with permitted suffering comprising post-release injuries assessed as sublethal. Furthermore, the legislation made a significant exception to the immediate killing requirements by exempting most fish. This failure to apply humane slaughter methods to large catches results in the legally permitted suffering of more than a billion fish in Finland each year.[158] Although a large number of stakeholders highlighted this obvious contradiction, the bill was not updated to include any mention of promoting technical solutions to implement humane slaughter or to express any objectives to change the situation in large-scale fishing. There was also no mention of the need to conduct a harm-benefit evaluation, which further manifests a lack of determination and goal setting to promote the welfare of fish with concrete measures. Commercial fishing constitutes a customary and normalised form of animal use, and the welfare of the fish is not regarded as sufficiently important to require investments in the fishing industry or a radical change in practices. This reflects the poor protection afforded to fish in the legislation, clearly differentiating fish from other vertebrates.

3. Respect and the Use of Fish for Entertainment

Recent years have witnessed the emergence of the notions of animal dignity and respect in European animal law.[159] For instance, the Netherlands, Norway, and Sweden have included statements on respect for animals in their animal welfare acts, while Switzerland incorporated the concept of ‘Würde der Kreatur’ into its Federal Constitution as early as 1999.[160] In welfarist law, regulations are justified on the basis of their effects on animal welfare; however, the objective of dignity-based animal law is not only to protect and promote the welfare of an individual animal but also to regulate human conduct that can impact its moral value.[161] The principle of respect is an emerging legal principle in Finnish animal welfare law; it is codified in the AWA but cannot yet be regarded as an established general principle in the Finnish legal system.[162] The ethical foundation lies in the view that animals possess intrinsic and/or final value, not only in relation to their function for humans (instrumental and/or extrinsic value). The claim of respect indicates an ethical stance that there is more to consider than just the animal’s welfare – that is, the concern that an animal may be disrespected not only by physical or mental pain but also by acts it may not experience as harmful. At the same time, respect is linked to welfare: denigrating actions can express an attitude that an animal is morally insignificant, which can lead to its treatment as a mere resource and, therefore, result in disregard for its welfare needs.[163]

Whereas animal sentience is a scientific fact, the question of intrinsic value is normative. Since lawmakers allow a harm-benefit analysis to be made, it is evident that the reference to an animal’s intrinsic value does not reflect an inherent value or dignity – that is, the animal is not regarded as an end in itself but primarily as an instrument for human purposes, whose welfare should be respected while being used. Hence, the mention of intrinsic value does not indicate an absolute demand to respect individual fish as such, but rather the obligation is relative to the situation. Consequently, the relevance of intrinsic value must be assessed in each decision; that is, the level of respect afforded to an animal’s sentience is relative to the perceived benefits of its use. As discussed by Kurki and Hehemann, dignity-based legislation seeks to accord a higher level of respect to animals as such, protecting them from instrumentalisation and promoting their flourishing, fostering a more egalitarian approach between species, and potentially hindering genetic modification.[164] Although such an elaborate approach is not visible within the Finnish AWA, the message of ideally thinking in terms of respect for individual animals is evident. However, operating within a welfarist paradigm, Finnish animal welfare regulations are primarily justified on the basis of their impact on animal welfare.[165]

The concept of respect was not mentioned in the amendment to the Fishing Act, as the new provisions were anchored in the concept of suffering. However, the general requirements in the AWA regarding respectful treatment and the prohibition on killing for entertainment, both rooted in the AWA’s objective to increase respect for animals, sparked stakeholder comments on two fishing practices that are controversial in Finnish society: voluntary C&R and fishing competitions. Animal advocacy organisations, in particular, but also animal welfare researchers and authorities, questioned recreational C&R, claiming that it caused unnecessary suffering and demonstrated a lack of respect for fish. Additionally, animal advocacy organisations considered fishing competitions to constitute the use of animals for entertainment and therefore called for their prohibition, in line with the AWA’s ban on killing for entertainment. Indeed, the AWA includes the idea of respecting the life of an animal, which should be protected to the degree that ‘an acceptable reason’ is required for killing.[166] Koponen has suggested that, similar to the assessment of the necessity of suffering, the acceptability of killing animals in AWA is also considered in relation to the prevalent conceptions in society regarding the customary reasons for killing.[167] This may explain why fishing competitions were demarcated outside the definition of killing for entertainment in the AWA without further justification. In this way, despite the ambitious general provisions, the AWA did not profoundly challenge widely held fishing practices.

4. Epistemological Challenges

Our analysis demonstrated that perceiving fish as sentient beings presents an epistemological challenge for stakeholders with an interest in fishing, whereas animal welfare organisations are challenged by the lack of respect for individual fish in the AWA. The double standard separating fish from mammals and birds is evident at both the level of epistemology and the level of legislative protection afforded to fish. Unlike mammals and birds, fish are grouped into a single phenomenon in both the legislation and stakeholder responses, where little or no attention is paid to the diversity of species and their related physical and behavioural characteristics, even when discussing their capacities. Moreover, they are often perceived as lacking the capacities necessary to be understandable to us, such as familiar body language and vocalisations audible to humans in terrestrial environments. However, another point of departure for reasoning about our responsibility for fish could instead focus on our inability to understand the agency of another sentient being – capable of interacting with conspecifics and its surroundings in a competent way – rather than viewing fish solely from the perspective of reproduction and sustainability. From this perspective, the limitations are on our side. This, in turn, leads to the question of how to act responsibly in relation to other sentient beings when we are largely unable to understand how our actions are perceived by them. In the specific case of fish, a further dimension is our tendency to misinterpret fish silence as a lack of inner experiences. Given benefit-of-the-doubt reasoning as an ethical foundation, respect for the unknown is not necessarily a challenge; rather, it is an opportunity to revise our perception of our position as the knowledgeable party in this equation.

In her essay ‘Difficulty of Reality and the Difficulty of Philosophy’, Cora Diamond elaborates on how our sense of ethical standards is challenged when communities lack a consensus on animal sentience and their treatment in farming, or the ethical dimensions of these phenomena.[168] She combines this question with a focus on the capacities we share with animals. Although Diamond’s reflection concerns reactions to standardised harm inflicted on animals in conventional farming, her analysis provides an interesting perspective on the epistemological challenges related to fish capacities. Diamond reflects on how even ‘a single exposure’ to a situation might become mind-challenging when we are unable to grasp and comprehend it, when reality seems ‘resistant to our thinking it, or possibly to be painful in its inexplicability, difficult in that way, or perhaps awesome and astonishing in its inexplicability.’[169] This can, she argues, lead to reflection on the limitations of thinking, but it can also trigger emotional or intellectual pain. Moreover, others might not share our experience of the limits of language or our resistance to (emotionally and intellectually) grasping the situation; that is, they might not experience the same difficulty in a given situation.[170]

Legislators’ reference to public acceptance of causing harm to animals as a self-evident point of departure highlights such a gap between stakeholder opinions. Some express a struggle to grasp a situation of standardised disrespect and systematic harm, whereas others do not perceive the treatment of fish entailing any difficulty. Such an effort to comprehend the reality of the suffering of huge numbers of individual fish in fishing competitions, C&R, and large-scale fishing might be a common experience among stakeholders calling for detailed legislative alignment between the AWA and the amendment of the Fishing Act regarding the consideration of individual fish welfare. By contrast, stakeholders who resisted improvements to fish welfare expressed no difficulty in grasping the situation; rather, they questioned research on fish sentience and highlighted the recreational value of the hobby in their efforts to advocate for the status quo. The former group sought to give voice to a silent agent in need of protection, whereas the latter expressed concern about limiting human interests.

These differing perceptions of fish welfare and what is ethically at stake may be rooted in the epistemological challenges visible among stakeholders due to holding varying perceptions of and trust in scientific evidence regarding fish capacities. If one denies fish sentience, both respect and empathy for them are removed from the equation. What remains is a balancing of harms and benefits, weighing the interests of an impersonal entity and a natural resource against social traditions. This anthropocentric point of view may be difficult to grasp for someone who, conversely, trusts scientific evidence that each individual fish caught and landed without immediate killing suffers while suffocating to death. It then becomes a challenge that the legislation is reluctant to prioritise science, choosing instead to allow societal concerns – that is, public acceptance of conventional treatment – to serve as the threshold.

Diamond further elaborates on the role of empathy by reflecting on the vulnerability humans share with other animals, from the point of departure that each of us may become ‘a wounded animal’.[171] Her reasoning can be summarised in three elements: first, that a person can be ‘haunted by the horror of what we do to animals’; second, that there however are individual variations between people, which can lead to different emotional responses to the state of the art; and third, that the experience of others not being emotionally affected by the reality of what animals endure in conventional farming may create an additional burden.[172] She asks, ‘how it is possible to live in the face of (...) the fact that for nearly everyone, it [animal suffering] is a nothing (…) the mere accepted background of life?’[173] A person who recognises the suffering of animals and potentially experiences isolation from others who neither see nor react to reality in the same way may therefore perceive themselves as ‘a wounded animal’.

In the context of the public consultation on fish legislation, such a reaction would imply that not only are fish silent, but that their advocates, too, risk becoming silent – haunted by exposure to the reality of fish suffering and the realisation that most people aware of the same facts are not concerned. Criticising societal norms and acting as a whistleblower in situations of institutionalised injustice carries the risk of isolation or exposure to negative attitudes from the majority, such as when expressing an ethical stance in favour of more respect for individual fish. Public consultations can therefore function as a safe space in which these perspectives are made visible and recorded. However, if their ambition to give voice to shared vulnerability does not prevail in the final legal outcome, it remains the difficult task of ‘the haunted’ to close the epistemological gap by making what is clearly visible to them (fish sentience and systematic harm) ethically relevant to society at large.

The challenge for lawmakers is not only to accommodate different views of reality but also to understand what is at stake: either managing a natural resource sustainably to safeguard human interests in a hobby accepted by a large proportion of the public or signalling trust in scientific evidence and precautionary ethical reasoning by formulating coherent legal requirements for the treatment of animals, regardless of whether the animal ranks high or low on the sociozoological scale.

VII. Conclusion

In this article, our analysis has demonstrated that the legal treatment of fish is characterised by notable internal tensions. As phylogenetically distant animals, fish evoke limited public empathy and are perceived as less emotionally and cognitively capable, increasing the risk that their welfare needs are inadequately recognised and protected in public policies.[174] In addition, rather than appreciating them as part of wildlife in their own right, public knowledge of fish is predominantly framed within the context of their use for food, as commodities in fisheries, and as sources of recreation. Our analysis reveals the dual position of fish – both as sentient beings and as natural resources – in official reasoning and stakeholder opinions. The AWA’s core principles demand that fish be respected as sentient individuals with subjective experiences and intrinsic value. The explicit introduction of pain and suffering into the Fishing Act represents a conceptual step forward, while the inclusion of animal welfare norms regarding the killing of fish in fishing legislation promotes more humane practices among anglers. However, the detailed provisions reveal a contrasting attitude that stems from a resource-based perspective: a viability assessment rather than a welfare assessment is used to evaluate the condition of fish intended for release, while no explicit stance is taken on C&R for entertainment, and large-scale fisheries are exempt from humane slaughter requirements.

Our analysis also highlights how appeals to customary and publicly accepted practices shape the interpretation of what counts as necessary suffering and an acceptable reason for killing animals. This reliance on convention, combined with doubts about fish sentience among influential fishing actors, undermines both the science-based ambitions and the ethical aspirations of the AWA. The result is a set of double standards that differentiates fish sharply from other vertebrates and limits the transformative potential of the new legislation. Drawing on Cora Diamond, we suggest that the consultation process exposes not only conflicting factual claims about fish capacities, but also divergent capacities to be affected by fish suffering. Public consultation thus plays a vital role in giving voice to those who perceive fish as vulnerable individuals, even when their views do not determine the final legal text.

To improve the status of aquatic animals in welfare legislation, we suggest the following. First, legislators should more consistently utilise up-to-date research on fish pain and suffering in law-preparation and adopt a precautionary, benefit-of-the-doubt stance where uncertainties remain. Improved structures are required to gather available evidence and assess scientific certainty, such as structured expert consultation processes, to inform legislative drafting in the development of animal welfare regulations concerning wild animals. Second, the harm-benefit reasoning that underpins animal welfare law should be made explicit in the context of fishing, including commercial and recreational practices, rather than shielding customary uses from scrutiny. Structured ethical assessment protocols should be used when legislating practices that affect the welfare of wild aquatic animals. Finally, to incorporate the perspectives of silent agents who are excluded from participatory law-making processes, specific institutional mechanisms, such as independent scientific advisory panels, are necessary to help society interpret their interests respectfully within policy development. The difficulty of understanding the subjective experiences of fish and determining what constitutes their interests calls for a strong institutional voice within the policy process to compensate for the risk that policymakers and the wider public may fail to understand them adequately. These actors could play an important role in communicating current scientific knowledge on fish sentience and welfare needs.

VIII. Statements and Declarations

Author Contributions: Conceptualisation S.K., H.R., A.V., L.H.; methodology, S.K.; formal analysis, S.K.; investigation, S.K., H.R.; writing – original draft preparation, S.K., H.R., A.V., L.H., writing – review and editing, S.K., H.R., A.V., L.H.; supervision, A.V.; funding acquisition, A.V., L.H.

Conflict of interest: Three of the authors commented on the draft Bill for the Animal Welfare Act and related acts during the consultation round, and the statements (two items) have been used as part of the material analysed for this study.

Funding statement: This work was supported by the Strategic Research Council within the Research Council of Finland (grant number 358268).

Acknowledgements: We thank Sara Blinnikka for conducting an initial analysis of the material, which was utilised as a starting point for the subsequent analysis. We thank Satu Raussi and Tiina Kauppinen of the Finnish Centre for Animal Welfare for providing information on fish count statistics in terms of individual numbers and legislation on catch-and-release fishing in other jurisdictions. We are also grateful to the anonymous reviewer for their valuable comments and suggestions.

[1] Alison Mood and Phil Brooke, ‘Estimating Global Numbers of Fishes Caught from the Wild Annually from 2000 to 2019’ (2024) 33 Animal Welfare e6.

[2] Sonia Rey Planellas and others, ‘Fish Welfare in a Changing World: New Developments and Current Challenges’ (2026) 109 Journal of Fish Biology 650, 674–675.

[3] Helena Röcklinsberg, ‘Fish Consumption: Choices in the Intersection of Public Concern, Fish Welfare, Food Security, Human Health and Climate Change’ (2015) 28 Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 533; Lynne U Sneddon, ‘Can Fish Experience Pain?’ in Tore S Kristiansen and others (eds), The Welfare of Fish (Springer International Publishing 2020).

[4] Mike Breen and others, ‘Catch Welfare in Commercial Fisheries’ in Tore S Kristiansen and others (eds), The Welfare of Fish (Springer International Publishing 2020); Rey Planellas and others (n 2).

[5] Steven J Cooke and Lynne U Sneddon, ‘Animal Welfare Perspectives on Recreational Angling’ (2007) 104 Applied Animal Behaviour Science 176; Breen and others (n 4); Rey Planellas and others (n 2).

[6] Natural Resources Institute Finland, ‘Recreational Fishing 2024’ (30 October 2025) <www.luke.fi/en/statistics/recreational-fishing/recreational-fishing-2024> accessed 3 July 2026.

[7] Mood and Brooke (n 1).

[8] Natural Resources Institute Finland, Statistics Database, ‘Fishery catch in Finland (1 000 kg) 1980-‘ <https://
statdb.luke.fi/PxWeb/pxweb/en/LUKE/LUKE__kal__zzz_lak__08%20Kalastus%20yhteensa/03_Kokonaiskalansaalis.px/> accessed 29 June 2026.

[9] Malcolm F Rosenthal and others, ‘Taxonomic Bias in Animal Behaviour Publications’ (2017) 127 Animal Behaviour 83.

[10] Michelle Sinclair and others, ‘International Perceptions of Animals and the Importance of Their Welfare’ (2022) 3 Frontiers in Animal Science 960379.

[11] Aurélien Miralles, Michelle Raymond and Guillaume Lecointre, ‘Empathy and Compassion toward Other Species Decrease with Evolutionary Divergence Time’ (2019) 9 Scientific Reports 19555.

[12] Ibid. See also Culum Brown, ‘Fish Intelligence, Sentience and Ethics’ (2015) 18 Animal Cognition 1.

[13] Abbie M Wilkins, Lucy S McCrae and E Anne McBride, ‘Factors Affecting the Human Attribution of Emotions toward Animals’ (2015) 28 Anthrozoös 357; Saara Kupsala and others, ‘Public Perceptions of Mental Capacities of Nonhuman Animals: Finnish Population Survey’ (2016) 24 Society & Animals 445; Megan M Callahan, Terre Satterfield and Jiaying Zhao, ‘Into the Animal Mind: Perceptions of Emotive and Cognitive Traits in Animals’ (2021) 34 Anthrozoös 597; Agnese Crisante, Oliver HP Burman and Anna Wilkinson, ‘All Is Not Equal: Public Perception of Cognitive Abilities, Suffering and Emotional Attachment in Different Pet Species’ (2024) 280 Applied Animal Behaviour Science 106434.

[14] Brown (n 11); Marianne E Lien, Becoming Salmon: Aquaculture and the Domestication of a Fish (University of California Press 2015); Röcklinsberg (n 3).

[15] Röcklinsberg (n 3).

[16] Frida Lundmark and others, ‘Intentions and Values in Animal Welfare Legislation and Standards’ (2014) 27 Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 991; Raffael Fasel and Sean C Butler, Animal Rights Law (Hart Publishing 2023); Visa AJ Kurki, ‘What is Animal Dignity in Law?’ (2025) LEOH – Journal of Animal Law, Ethics and One Health 9.

[17] Veerle Platvoet, ‘Unearthing Wild Animal Law: A Theory on the Foundations of the European Regime for Wild Animals’ (DPhil Thesis, University of Helsinki 2025) 112. See also Röcklinsberg (n 3).

[18] Robert Garner, A Theory of Justice for Animals: Animal Rights in a Nonideal World (Oxford University Press 2013) 89; Platvoet (n 17).

[19] James W Yeates, Helena Röcklinsberg and Mickey Gjerris, ‘Is Welfare All That Matters? A Discussion of What Should Be Included in Policy-Making Regarding Animals’ (2011) 20 Animal Welfare 423; Kurki (n 16).

[20] The construction of the interests of farm animals in stakeholder opinions submitted during the drafting of the Finnish Animal Welfare Act has been analysed by Matias Koivulehto and Tomi Lehtimäki in ‘Epistemic Struggles in Legislating Animal Welfare in Finland: Competing Constructions of the Public Interest’ (2025) 52 Journal of Law and Society 628.

[21] Act on the Amendment of the Fishing Act (695/2023).

[22] Birgitta Wahlberg and others, Nordic Animal Law: Welfare and Rights (Ethics International Press 2024) 140–174; Government Bill for the Fishing Act (192/2014).

[23] Fishing Act (379/2015) s 3; Consolidated Version of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) [2016] OJ C202/1.

[24] TFEU (n 22); Fabio Grati and others, ‘Effective Governance of Marine Recreational Fisheries in Europe Is Needed to Maximize the Societal Benefits of Its Fisheries’ (2025) 82 ICES Journal of Marine Science fsae169; Alice Di Concetto and Pauline Koczorowski, The Protection of Wild-Caught Fish in EU Law (The European Institute for Animal Law & Policy 2023).

[25] Ministry of Justice, ‘Hallituksen esitysten laatimisohjeet: Opas hyvien esitysten kirjoittamiseen’ [‘Guidelines for Drafting Government Proposals: A Guide to Writing Effective Proposals’] (2019) <https://helo.finlex.fi> accessed 30 June 2026.

[26] Ministry of Justice, ‘Säädösvalmistelun kuulemisopas’ [‘Guide to Public Comment Procedures in Legislative Drafting’] (2016) <https://kuulemisopas.finlex.fi/> accessed 30 June 2026.

[27] Jean Loup Rault and others, ‘A Consensus on the Definition of Positive Animal Welfare’ (2025) 21 Biology Letters 3.

[28] Visa AJ Kurki and Paulina Siemieniec, ‘Towards an Agency Turn in Animal Law’ (2025) Oxford Journal of Legal Studies. See also Sue Donaldson and Will Kymlicka, Zoopolis: A Political Theory of Animal Rights (Oxford University Press 2011).

[29] Kati Rantala and others, ‘Exploring Dilemmas and Depoliticization in Inclusive Lawmaking: The Perspective of Silent Agents’ (2026) 20 Critical Policy Studies 97.

[30] Ibid.

[31] Donaldson and Kymlicka (n 28) 153–154.

[32] EFSA Panel on Animal Health and Welfare, ‘Scientific Opinion of the Panel on Animal Health and Welfare on a Request from the European Commission on General Approach to Fish Welfare and to the Concept of Sentience in Fish’ (2009) EFSA Journal 1.

[33] Inonge Reimert and others, ‘Review: Towards an Integrated Concept of Animal Welfare’ (2023) 17 Animal: An International Journal of Animal Bioscience 100838 7.

[34] Georgia J Mason and J Michelle Lavery, ‘What Is It Like to Be a Bass? Red Herrings, Fish Pain and the Study of Animal Sentience’ (2022) 9 Frontiers in Veterinary Science 788289.

[35] EFSA Panel on Animal Health and Welfare (n 32).

[36] Ibid.; Lauri Urho and others, ‘Fish’ in Esko Hyvärinen and others (eds), The 2019 Red List of Finnish Species (Ministry of the Environment & Finnish Environment Institute 2019).

[37] Lynne U Sneddon, ‘Pain in Aquatic Animals’ (2015) 218 Journal of Experimental Biology 967.

[38] Ibid.

[39] Tore S Kristiansen and Anders Fernö, ‘The Predictive Brain: Perception Turned Upside Down’ in Tore S Kristiansen and others (eds), The Welfare of Fish (Springer International Publishing 2020).

[40] Anders Fernö and others, ‘Inside the Fish Brain: Cognition, Learning and Consciousness’ in Tore S Kristiansen and others (eds), The Welfare of Fish (Springer International Publishing 2020) 203.

[41] Becca Franks, Jeff Sebo and Alexandra Horowitz, ‘Fish are Smart and Feel Pain: What About Joy?’ (2018) 21 Animal Sentience.

[42] Crisante and others (n 13).

[43] Sinclair and others (n 10).

[44] Clive JC Phillips and Steven McCulloch, ‘Student Attitudes on Animal Sentience and Use of Animals in Society’ (2005) 40 Journal of Biological Education 17N; McGrath and others, ‘Public Attitudes towards Grief in Animals’ (2013) 22 Animal Welfare 33; Wilkins and others (n 13); Callahan and others (n 13); Crisante and others (n 13).

[45] Maria Ioannidou and others, ‘Minding Some Animals but Not Others: Strategic Attributions of Mental Capacities and Moral Worth to Animals Used for Food in Pescatarians, Vegetarians, and Omnivores’ (2024) 200 Appetite 107559.

[46] Kupsala and others (n 13).

[47] Pekka Salmi and Outi Ratamäki, ‘Fishing Culture, Animal Policy, and New Governance: A Case Study of Voluntary Catch-and-Release Fishing in Finland’ in Douglas T Beard, Robert Arlinghaus and Stephen G Sutton (eds), The Angler in the Environment: Social, Economic, Biological, and Ethical Dimensions. The Proceedings of the 5th World Recreational Fishing Conference (2011); Robert Arlinghaus and others, ‘Global Participation in and Public Attitudes Toward Recreational Fishing: International Perspectives and Developments’ (2021) 29 Reviews in Fisheries Science & Aquaculture 58.

[48] Matti O Hannikainen, ‘Classifying Finnish Fish’ in Taina Syrjämaa and others (eds), Animal Industries: Nordic Perspectives on the Exploitation of Animals since 1860 (De Gruyter 2024).

[49] Jukka Mikkola and Rauno Yrjölä, Suomalainen vapaa-ajankalastaja ja -kalastus vuosituhannen vaihtuessa (Finnish Game and Fisheries Research Institute, 2003).

[50] Timo Haapasalo, ‘Kestävyyden käytännöt uhanalaisten lohikalojen virkistyskalastuksessa’ [‘Practices of Sustainability in Recreational Fishing for Endangered Salmonids’] (DPhil Thesis, University of Eastern Finland 2024).

[51] Jani Pellikka and Päivi Eskelinen, Vapaa-ajankalastajien profiilit [Profiles of Recreational Anglers] (Natural Resources Institute Finland, 2019).

[52] Urho and others 2019 (n 36).

[53] Government Degree on Fishing (1360/2015); Urho and others (n 36).

[54] Government Bill for the Fishing Act (192/2014). See also Haapasalo ‘Practices of Sustainability in Recreational Fishing for Endangered Salmonids’ (n 50).

[55] Breen and others (n 4).

[56] Ibid.; Keno Ferter and others, ‘Fish Welfare in Recreational Fishing’ in Tore S Kristiansen and others (eds), The Welfare of Fish (Springer International Publishing 2020).

[57] Benjamin K Diggles, ‘Development of Resources to Promote Best Practice in the Humane Dispatch of Finfish Caught by Recreational Fishers’ (2016) 23 Fisheries Management and Ecology 200.

[58] Ibid.

[59] Heikki Uusitalo, ‘Kohdeltiinko Kemissä pidetyn pilkkikisan saaliskaloja väärin?’ [‘Were the fish caught in the ice fishing competition held in Kemi treated improperly?’] Kaleva (Oulu, 27 January 2020) <www.kaleva.fi/kohdeltiinko-kemissa-pidetyn-pilkkikisan-saaliskal/1656121> accessed 30 June 2026.

[60] Breen and others (n 4); Katy L James and others, ‘Humane Stunning or Stun/Killing in the Slaughter of Wild-Caught Finfish: The Scientific Evidence Base’ (2025) 34 Animal Welfare e33.

[61] Rey Planellas and others (n 2) 674–675.

[62] R Muir and others, ‘Attitudes towards Catch-And-Release Recreational Angling, Angling Practices and Perceptions of Pain and Welfare in Fish in New Zealand’ (2013) 22 Animal Welfare 323.

[63] Ibid.

[64] Daniel Santiago Rucinque, Ana Paula Oliveira Souza and Carla Forte Maiolino Molento, ‘Perception of Fish Sentience, Welfare and Humane Slaughter by Highly Educated Citizens of Bogotá, Colombia and Curitiba, Brazil’ (2017) 12 PLOS ONE e0168197.

[65] Ibid.

[66] Ibid.

[67] Mikkola and Yrjöjä (n 49).

[68] Ibid.

[69] Ibid.; Pellikka and Eskelinen (n 51).

[70] Mikkola and Yrjölä (n 49); Cooke and Sneddon (n 5).

[71] Cooke and Sneddon (n 5).

[72] Ibid.

[73] Ibid.

[74] Ibid.

[75] Ibid.

[76] Breen and others (n 4).

[77] Salmi and Ratamäki (n 47).

[78] Ibid.

[79] Mikkola and Yrjöjä (n 49); Timo Haapasalo, ’Kestävyyttä kohden? Kalastuksen säätelyn tietoperustaisuus ja hyväksyttävyys Lieksanjoen Ruunaan koskilla’ [’Toward Sustainability? The Evidence Base and Acceptability of Fisheries Management at the Ruuna Rapids on the Lieksanjoki River’] (2021) 29 Maaseutututkimus 32.

[80] Timo Haapasalo, ‘Kestävyysvajeesta tietoperustaisuuteen: kalastuksen säätely kestävyysmurroksen instrumenttina’ [’From Sustainability Shortfalls to Knowledge-Based Regulation: Fisheries Management as an Instrument for Sustainability Transformation’] (2024) 53 Alue ja Ympäristö 70.

[81] Ibid; Haapasalo ’Toward Sustainability?’ (n 79).

[82] Vonne Lund and others, ‘Expanding the Moral Circle: Farmed Fish as Objects of Moral Concern’ (2007) 75 Diseases of Aquatic Organisms 109; Frank LB Meijboom and Bernice Bovenkerk, ‘Fish Welfare: Challenge for Science and Ethics – Why Fish Makes the Difference’ (2013) 26 Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 1; Bernice Bovenkerk and Frank LB Meijboom, ‘Fish Welfare in Aquaculture: Explicating the Chain of Interactions Between Science and Ethics’ (2013) 26 Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 41; Röcklinsberg (n 3).

[83] The unofficial translation by the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry of the name of the statute (247/1996) is ‘Animal Welfare Act’, but the Finnish name ‘Eläinsuojelulaki’ literally means ‘Animal Protection Act’. The same applies to the name of the decree. We use the literal translation here because it is central to emphasise the change in the name of the act, manifesting the shift in the primary focus of the act from the protection of animals from suffering and other negative states to promoting their welfare in a broader sense.

[84] Veera Koponen, ‘Eläinsuojeluoikeus: Suomen eläinsuojeluoikeuden yleiset opit eurooppalaisen valtiosääntöoikeuden viitekehyksessä’ [‘Animal Welfare Law: General Principles of Finnish Animal Welfare Law within the Framework of European Constitutional Law’] (DPhil Thesis, University of Helsinki 2025) 35–36.

[85] Animal Welfare Act (693/2023) ss 6, 12, 13, 64; Government Bill for the Animal Welfare Act and Related Acts 186/2022 88, 96, 98.

[86] Animal Welfare Act (693/2023) ss 7, 28, 29. The prohibition on capturing wild animals to be cared for was extended from mammalian and avian species in the APA (s 13) to all vertebrates in the AWA (s 28), thus covering fish as well. According to the AWA (s 5(1)(7)), a wild animal means ‘an animal belonging to a wild species living in nature, which was born in nature or raised to be released into nature, but not an animal that has escaped from human care and can be distinguished from animals born in nature’ (authors’ own translation). Wild animal species refers to ‘animal species whose genetic makeup has not been altered by humans via selective breeding’ (Bill 186/2022 83) (authors’ own translation).

[87] Animal Welfare Act (693/2023) s 64(5); Bill 186/2022 159.

[88] Koponen (n 84).

[89] Ibid 160–163.

[90] Ibid 178.

[91] Kurki (n 16) 13; Koponen (n 84) 83–85.

[92] Koponen (n 84) 83–84.

[93] The Fishing Act (379/2015) s 2.

[94] Animal Welfare Act (693/2023) s 6; Hunting Act (615/1993) s 20(1).

[95] Fishing Act (379/2015) s 1.

[96] The Government Proposal to Parliament for the Fishing Act and Certain Related Acts (Bill 192/2014) states that a central intention is ‘to create good conditions for commercial and recreational fishing’ (p. 1) and that the ‘Act aims to create a framework within which common fishing resources can be utilised sustainably’ (p. 17) (authors’ translation, emphasis added). The resource approach is evident in the description of the annual catch in terms of weight rather than numbers of individuals and in providing a monetary value for the annual catch (p. 7).

[97] Fishing Act (379/2015) s 46.

[98] Ibid.

[99] In the Bill 192/2014 (p. 56), the prohibitions are justified by referring to the fact that the use of these methods is contrary to the objective of the Fishing Act concerning the ecological, social, and economic sustainability of fishing. The prohibited methods and equipment are ‘generally considered to unnecessarily destroy or endanger fish stocks or to damage fish’.

[100] Fishing Act (192/2014) s 55(1), s 56.

[101] Fishing Act (192/2014) s 55 (2).

[102] Fishing Act (192/2014) s 58(1-2).

[103] Bill 192/2014 66.

[104] Comp. Platvoet (n 17) 101. Platvoet notes that the prohibitions on the killing, capture, and disturbance of protected species in European Union conservation law also to a certain degree protect the welfare of individuals within the species in question, although the aims of the prohibitions are based on species conservation rather than animal welfare.

[105] Act on the Amendment of the Fishing Act (695/2023) s 58(3).

[106] Act on the Amendment of the Fishing Act (695/2023) s 58a.

[107] Koponen (n 84) 38.

[108] Fishing Act (192/2014) s 5. For instance, according to Haapasalo (n 50), some owners of rivers with salmonid fish prohibit the use of a gaff; however, binding requirements are often lacking, and certain practices that reduce injuries and stress, such as the use of barbless hooks and the avoidance of fishing in elevated water temperatures, are only recommended. The state-owned organisation Metsähallitus (English: Forestry Commission) sells fishing permits for state-owned water areas and has published guidelines on responsible fishing. When water temperatures exceed 21 °C, the commission may temporarily suspend the sale of permits for fishing salmonids. However, the commission has not introduced any binding rules and only recommends certain practices in its guidelines. The commission recommends, for instance, reducing the number of hooks, using barbless hooks and knotless landing nets, avoiding the prolonged tiring of the fish, especially in warm waters, releasing fish underwater, and, if not possible, handling fish on wet surfaces and with wet hands. Metsähallitus, ‘Guidelines for responsible fishing’ (no date) <www.eraluvat.fi/en/fishing/fisher-s-information-bank/guidelines-for-responsible-fishing> accessed 1 July 2026.

[109] Fishing Act (192/2014) s 53.

[110] Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, ‘Draft Government Proposal to the Parliament for the Act on Animal Welfare and Certain Related Acts’ (4 November 2021) (henceforth draft Bill).

[111] The materials from the public consultation (stakeholder organisations’ comments and summaries) are available on the website of the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry of Finland (<mmm.fi/hanke2?tunnus=MMM051:00/2020>, accessed 1 July 2026). In addition to comments from stakeholder organisations, the MAF received 300 opinions from individual citizens. However, these individual submissions were not published on the website; only a summary was made available. Koivulehto and Lehtimäki (n 20) have analysed the construction of farm animal interests in the stakeholder opinions.

[112] Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, ‘Lausuntokooste, sidosryhmien antamat lausunnot – Luonnos laiksi eläinten hyvinvoinnista ja laeiksi eräiden siihen liittyvien lakien muuttamisesta’ [‘Summary of Comments, Comments Submitted by Stakeholders – Draft Act on Animal Welfare and Acts Amending Certain Related Acts’ (29 March 2022) <mmm.fi/documents/1410837/0/Lausuntokooste_kaikki+sidosryhmien+kommentit_EHL+HE.pdf/
2f8def98-596e-068f-28c8-94381715f2e9/Lausuntokooste_kaikki+sidosryhmien+kommentit_EHL+HE.pdf?t=1649844828817> (accessed 1 July 2026).

[113] The Finnish words ‘kala*’ and ‘kalo*’ were used in the word search.

[114] The analysed material included a comment submitted by the first author in her previous role as the Animal Welfare Ombudsman, while the second and third authors contributed to the comment submitted by the Faculty of Veterinary Medicine at the University of Helsinki, which was also part of the analysed material. These comments were analysed and thematically coded in the same manner as all other material. However, no direct quotations from the comment submitted by the Animal Welfare Ombudsman are included in the article. The second and third authors did not participate in the analysis of the material.

[115] The AI-based DeepL Translator was utilised to assist with the translations.

[116] Animal Welfare Act (693/2023) s 5(1). The definition was included in the act itself after the comments round. In the draft bill (p. 75), the concept of animal welfare was defined in the detailed motivation of Section 1 as ‘an animal’s experience of its own psychological and physical state’.

[117] Draft Bill 83; Bill 186/2022 88–89.

[118] Draft Bill 201; Bill 186/2022 216–217.

[119] Benjamin K Diggles and others, ‘Reasons to Be Sceptical about Sentience and Pain in Fishes and Aquatic Invertebrates’ (2024) 32 Reviews in Fisheries Science & Aquaculture 127.

[120] A full reference included in the comment: Howard I Browman and others, ‘Welfare of Aquatic Animals: Where Things Are, Where They Are Going, And What It Means for Research, Aquaculture, Recreational Angling, And Commercial Fishing’ (2019) 76 ICES Journal of Marine Science 82.

[121] A full reference included in the comment: Browman and others (n 120).

[122] Draft Bill 75; Bill 186/2022 81.

[123] Ibid.

[124] Ibid.

[125] Draft Bill 83; Bill 186/2022 88.

[126] Draft Bill 267.

[127] Draft Bill 201.

[128] Draft Bill 201.

[129] Bill 186/2022 289; Act on the Amendment of the Fishing Act (695/2023).

[130] Bill 186/2022 217. Anglers are prohibited from retaining any fish that is legally required to be returned to the water, even if the fish is dead or fatally injured and must be killed (Fishing Act (192/2014) ss 55, 58). If an angler retains a protected, endangered fish, they may be liable to pay compensation for the fish’s conservation value (The Federation of Finnish Fisheries Associations, ‘Lohikalojen syysrauhoitus alkaa’ [‘The Autumn Closed Season for Salmonid Fish Begins’] (28 August 2026) <https://ahven.net/artikkeli/2026/08/28/lohikalojen-rauhoitus-alkaa/#pll_switcher> accessed 20 September 2026).

[131] Draft Bill 201; Bill 186/2022 217.

[132] Draft Bill 151; Bill 186/2022 159.

[133] Draft Bill 75; Bill 186/2022 81.

[134] Ibid.

[135] Draft Bill 76; Bill 186/2022 81.

[136] Ibid.

[137] Draft Bill 83; Bill 186/2022 88.

[138] Ibid.

[139] Draft Bill 151; Bill 186/2022 159.

[140] Ibid.

[141] Ibid.

[142] Ibid.

[143] Draft Bill 201; Bill 186/2022 217.

[144] Ibid. The law includes a legislative delegation authority where it is possible to specify in a Government Decree what a large catch means.

[145] After the comments round, an addition to the amendment to the Fishing Act stated that the death of fish should be confirmed before their further processing, a requirement similar to that in the AWA (see Appendix A). It is possible that legislators noticed this omission in the proposed amendment and corrected it in the final bill, but this particular issue was not commented on during the public consultation.

[146] Kupsala and others (n 13).

[147] Brock Bastian and others, ‘Don’t Mind Meat? The Denial of Mind to Animals Used for Human Consumption’ (2011) 38 Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 247.

[148] Lund and others (n 82); Jonathan Birch, ‘Animal Sentience and the Precautionary Principle’ (2017) 16 Animal Sentience.

[149] Lien (n 14); Röcklinsberg (n 3). This applies also to insect rearing and consumption, see: Mickey Gjerris, Christian Gamborg and Helena Röcklinsberg, ‘Ethical Aspects of Insect Production for Food and Feed’ (2016) 2 Journal of Insects as Food and Feed 101.

[150] Arnold Arluke and Clinton R Sanders, Regarding Animals (Temple University Press 1996) 169–186.

[151] In a similar vein, Platvoet (n 17, p. 97) has noted the dual status of wild animals in European conservation law: on the one hand, they are sentient beings, as proclaimed in the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, and, on the other hand, they are living resources as components of biodiversity.

[152] Koponen (n 84) 156.

[153] Ibid 157, 161.

[154] Kurki (n 16) 12.

[155] Dominik Hajosi and Herwig Grimm, ‘Mission Impossible Accomplished? A European Cross-National Comparative Study on The Integration of The Harm-Benefit Analysis into Law and Policy Documents’ (2024) 19 PLOS ONE e0297375.

[156] Patrick Bateson, ‘When to Experiment on Animals’ (1986) 109 New Scientist 30; Hajosi and Grimm (n 156);

Helena Röcklinsberg and others, ‘The Ethical Assessment Process’ in Mickey Gjerris and others (eds), Biotech Animals in Research: Ethical and Regulatory Aspects (CRC Press 2024).

[157] E.g. Cooke and Sneddon (n 4); Ferter and others (n 56).

[158] In 2024, 76 per cent of the total catch by weight came from commercial fishing (Natural Resources Institute Finland (n 8)). An estimate suggests that the annual Finnish catch consists of 2.8 billion individuals (Mood and Brooke 2024 (n 1)).

[159] Kurki (n 16).

[160] Klaus P Rippe, ‘Die Würde des Tieres als Bürde des Gesetzgebers: Zur Revision des Tierschutzgesetzes unter dem Aspekt der Würde der Kreatur’ (2000) Forschung für Leben; Wahlberg and others (n 22); Rosa M Cajiga and others, ‘Cross-Jurisdictional Study of the 3Rs: A Comparative Legal Analysis of Animal Research Governance in Finland and Switzerland’ (2026) LEOH – Journal of Animal Law, Ethics and One Health 62.

[161] Kurki (n 16) 12.

[162] Koponen (n 84) 211.

[163] Kurki (n 16).

[164] Lena Hehemann, ‘The Protection of the Dignity of Laboratory Animals in Switzerland: Different Procedures? Different Standards?’ (2018) 6 Global Journal of Animal Law 2; Kurki (n 16). See also Rippe (n 160); Eva Bernet Kempers, ‘If Rivers Have Rights, do Fish Have Rights Too? Examining the Relationship Between Rights of Nature and Animal Rights’ (2026) LEOH – Journal of Animal Law, Ethics and One Health 4.

[165] Koponen (n 84).

[166] Bill 186/2022 88; Koponen (n 84) 172–178.

[167] Koponen (n 84) 172.

[168] Cora Diamond, ‘The Difficulty of Reality and the Difficulty of Philosophy’ (2003) 1 Partial Answers: Journal of Literature and the History of Ideas 1.

[169] Ibid 2.

[170] Ibid.

[171] Ibid 3.

[172] Ibid.

[173] Ibid.

[174] Comp. Crisante and others (n 13).